not in Primary anymore

an open letter to utah republican leadership

TW: mentions assault, racism, sexism, homophobia



Dear Gary Herbert, Chris Stewart, Mike Lee, Jason Chaffetz, and every other member of the Utah (and national) Republican Leadership,

Hey. We need to talk.

I’ve been watching a lot of news recently (big weekend, huh?) and I saw your statements. While I would like to congratulate you for finally getting onto the same page as the rest of us, I also want to point something out.

As John Oliver noted in his weekly show, you all had some similar things to say about why you’re no longer voting for Trump. I commend you for having wives. And daughters. And sisters. But simply claiming possession of these human beings is not enough to excuse the fact that your have ignored Donald’s sexism, racism, xenophobia, homophobia, and general awfulness for more than a year.

But I don’t even want to talk about that. What I want to talk about is why your “support” of women means nothing to me.

I am a daughter. A sister. An aunt. Someday, I might be a wife or a mother. But I’m here, on the internet today, to tell you that I am a human being first.

Now, I don’t necessarily blame you for your misconceptions on this point. Not only are your misogynistic notions of my humanity reinforced by the patriarchal structure of US society, but you also belong to a church that teaches that a woman’s power comes from being a wife and mother. It’s easy to see how you might be confused.

But as a human being, I deserve rights and am guaranteed these rights by the Constitution you claim to defend. Rights like access to the health care I need. Rights like knowing that people of color in our community can trust law enforcement. Rights like being paid what I deserve for the work that I do. Rights like the ability to marry whomever I choose and not be discriminated against for it. Rights like sex-ed in public schools to keep myself safe. Rights like knowing that if I am raped or assaulted my attacker will be prosecuted. (Isn’t it interesting that your condemnation of Trump had nothing to do with the fact that he was talking about sexual assault and everything to do with the fact that it was your women he might be touching? Curious.)

And, as you’ll see if you click on any of the links in the paragraph above, Utah has a pretty awful track records for ALL of these things. That isn’t on Donald and his comments this weekend. That isn’t even on his general awfulness. That is on you and your unwillingness to actually stand up for the rights of the people in Utah.

So I’m writing you this letter today to let you know that I registered to vote this morning. That this year in Utah I not only have the chance to vote for the first female president, but also for the first trans woman and youngest person ever for the senate, for a candidate for Governor whom I originally met at a Planned Parenthood fundraiser, and for candidates who work with Equality Utah, Planned Parenthood, and other organizations that are protecting my rights against your attacks. 

I want you to know that I am registered to vote; I am excited to vote; and I will not be voting for you until the reality of my– of our– HUMANITY is more important to you than which privileged, white man can claim ownership of my existence.

6 Responses to “an open letter to utah republican leadership”

  1. Sara Jane

    Emma, you don’t NEED an abortion (what you so conveniently call “healthcare”), and no one has the legitimate right to kill an innocent human being. Did you know that Norma McCorvey, the plaintiff in roe vs. wade is now pro life? She said that the lawyers coerced her into fabricating a sorry that she had been raped to garner public sympathy. But she’s now fighting for life! I hope you will too 😀

    • Val

      Planned Parenthood is not just about abortions. They take care of women, they administer Pap smears, breast exams, family planning, plan B, and advice. A lot of women who live in low income areas don’t have a fancy gynecologist they can go to every six months, and planned parenthood offices lend a helping hand to them to get their very important check ups. So yeah, that’s what she means by healthcare. Furthermore, no government funds are used to pay for the minuscule percentage of abortions PP partakes of. And even if she personally does not “need an abortion”, she is standing up for the rights of other women to have a choice and a place to go. Making abortion illegal does not make them go away. It makes us more likely to go back to the alley-hanger times. Also, third trimester abortions (where the fetus is now more than a bundle of cells) are very rare, and never performed out of desire. Even if government funding is blocked to PP, people like me will keep donating and volunteering so that women of all sorts of economical needs will have access to the immense help that these clinics bring.

  2. Anonymous

    Can you cite any constitutonal provision, court case, or other authority confirming your belief that you have a constitutional right to healthcare, to trust the police, to be paid what you deserve, or to sex-ed classes? I’m pretty sure there is no such thing as to a constitutional right to those things.

    I completely agree that the Republicans should have dropped their support for Trump long ago. But you lose a lot of credibility on that point by making other claims that are patently false.

    • Modernist

      Bingo! These people think they have a right to this and that. Entitlement to the max. Take care of yourself, your family, and your circle, and don’t expect the government to coddle you.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Basic HTML is allowed. Your email address will not be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS

%d bloggers like this: