not in Primary anymore

the patriarchy needs to be “heckled”

by Hermia Lyly

Just yesterday I was talking to a friend about how angry I am about how the Church ignores its members who cry out for change. If you’ve ever tried to rally for change within the Church, you’ll probably understand how awful it is to feel voiceless, ignored, belittled, and invalidated. When I have attempted to express my concerns to Church leaders in the past, most of the conversations have gone along the following lines:

Me: I feel that you are dismissive of my concerns and opinions.

Church Leader: Well that’s not true.

Me: See, you just did it again!

Church Leader: Did what?

Me: You just dismissed my opinion. You are gaslighting me.

Church Leader: (unironically) No we aren’t.

I learned many years ago that going through the “proper” lines of authority in order to address my concerns would get me nowhere. When I was polite in sharing my concerns, they assumed that I wasn’t serious. When I was willing to wait for them, they assumed that if my concerns could wait, they must not really be that important at all. And when I stopped being polite and waiting for them, they blamed their ignorance of my struggles on my rudeness and my irrational, overemotional femininity and my wicked, sinful queerness.

Just last General Conference, a number of attendees from the group “Any Opposed?” stood up during the sustaining vote and publicly shouted “opposed!” when Elder Uchtdorf asked if any were opposed to sustaining the Church leadership. Afterwards, many Mormons felt it was their duty to condemn these attendees for yelling during General Conference, for being “disruptive” and “irreverent.” Instead of examining the reasons why “Any Opposed?” felt the need to voice their opinion, many people focused on tone-policing. They were more concerned about being polite and nice than they were about the legitimate grievances that “Any Opposed?” had regarding the Church’s racism and the Church’s failure to address its members’ needs.

Luckily, there were many Mormons who were able to see past this tone-policing. They were able to recognize that the members of “Any Opposed?” did not interrupt General Conference just for the sake of being rude–they interrupted General Conference because they were frustrated that they were not being heard by their local leaders, and they felt that only way they could be heard was by vocalizing publicly.

Unfortunately, some of the same people who defended “Any Opposed?” from tone-policing are currently engaged in tone-policing Jennicet Gutiérrez, a trans activist who is now gaining publicity for “heckling” President Obama at an LGBT event in the White House. Part of the reason some many people are tone-policing Jennicet Gutiérrez is because of the dreadfully poor reporting on the event. Many reporters failed to look into who Gutiérrez is or even what she was saying; they simply assumed that since a person was interrupting the President at an LGBT event, that person must automatically be homophobic, and therefore silencing them was okay. In the interest of getting a story out quickly, these reporters presented false information to millions of people.

To say that Jennicet Gutiérrez was “heckling” the President is to tone-police her. Gutiérrez did not attend the event to give the President a bad time, rather, she spoke truth to power in order to “demand respect and acknowledgement of our gender expression and the release of the estimated 75 transgender immigrants in detention right now. There is no pride in how LGBTQ immigrants are treated in this country and there can be no celebration with an administration that has the ability to keep us detained and in danger or release us to freedom” (full article here). The fact that President Obama, the attendees of the White House event, and millions of people online have chosen to focus on the way that Gutiérrez engaged with President Obama rather than what she had to say shows that we care more about being polite than we care about human rights and social justice. Gutiérrez interrupted the President because the plight of these transgender immigrants was consistently ignored and silenced, and interrupted him seemed like the only way to keep him from ignoring them yet again.

Systemic oppression will not be overthrown through waiting patiently, being nice, or speaking politely. If we wait until our oppressors are ready to hear our grievances, we’ll die waiting. So think twice before you dismiss Gutiérrez for disrespecting the President. After all, which is more disrespectful: interrupting a speech, or claiming to support LGBT rights while holding transgender people in detention and violating their basic human rights?

For more information:

https://www.washingtonblade.com/2015/06/25/exclusive-i-interrupted-obama-because-we-need-to-be-heard/

http://www.notonemoredeportation.com/2015/06/24/whpride/

http://www.advocate.com/commentary/2015/06/25/op-ed-you-cant-cheer-laverne-and-boo-jennicet

http://www.socialjusticeleague.net/2012/04/the-revolution-will-not-be-polite-the-issue-of-nice-versus-good/

https://thenib.com/great-moments-in-peaceful-protest-history-44bdadb44cf

Advertisements

4 Responses to “the patriarchy needs to be “heckled””

  1. sweentasia

    This is an idea I have always had trouble with because for me, it’s hard to outrightly appear rude. What will the good people of the world think?! But I’ve started to also become less and less patient. As Inigo Montoya would say, “I hate waiting.” There’s entire rooms dedicated to it, but enough is enough. Sometimes someone has to be willing to slap the proverbial glove across the face of those who aren’t paying attention and wake them up to reality; even if it’s not polite.

    Reply
  2. Ryan

    Entertaining. No wonder the feminist version of “the patriarchy” throughout history is what it is. Women love to feel oppressed. Keep whining and keep staying in this “abusive” relationship. You have battered wife syndrome.

    Reply
  3. Skippy

    Wow you seriously need to check your privilege. It seems to me that you would dictate to God how the church should be run. I’ve got news for you, it doesn’t work that way. Look at the Doctrine and Covenants. It’s full of direct revelation coming directly from Christ correcting bad behavior in an entirely male fashion. I n a way that is direct and to the point, leaving no room for man’s wants. The law of Christ is just that; a law. It cannot be reshaped, reformed or changed by men. Would you reshape the church to be molded to your personal beliefs? Or would you kneel before the Lord and have some faith and humility in your maker? At the end of the day you have a choice that everyone shares. Either do as the church asks, or don’t. But don’t get all butt hurt when you go against the church and it tells you that you are doing something wrong. Your view of the whole Obama thing is way off the mark too. All you can see is what you chose to see. If there are 75 immigrants being held in the justice system the first thing you go to is that they are LGBT and need special treatment? What about every other person on the face of the earth that is incarcerated? You would marginalize their suffering? The biggest thing that irritates me the most is that you haven’t even looked at what these people where charged with. There isn’t even a glimmer of this question: Did they break the law? And if so being LGBT should be a non issue. But you would have them overlook the law and just release them based on their sexual orientation? Do me a favor. There are members that go teach Sunday school to the incarcerated every week. I dare you to go with them and to look those individuals in the face and to take a measure of their well being. I’m willing to bet that NONE of them are concerned with being LGBT at that time. I’m also willing to bet that each one of them shows you what it means to be humble and repentant with a desire to change. Then go home and take a good hard look into yourself and check your privilege. Stop choosing to be a victim and grow a pair already.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Basic HTML is allowed. Your email address will not be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS

%d bloggers like this: